Lease versus buy, in practical terms
Buying with a loan means you pay interest on the financed amount and you own the car — including its depreciation and its resale value — when the loan ends or when you sell it. Leasing is closer to paying for the depreciation the lender expects during the term, plus a rent charge set by the money factor, plus fees. At the end of a closed-end lease you typically return the car, subject to mileage and wear charges, unless you buy it at the residual.
This calculator finances the purchase price plus estimated sales tax and fees, minus cash down and trade-in. You can choose whether a trade-in reduces the taxable amount, which is how some states treat it. The buy-side “total cost” over your hold period is a simplified cash view: down payment, loan payments during the years you keep the car, any remaining balance, minus expected resale. If you keep the car after the loan is paid off, a higher resale (or a longer hold) usually improves the buy case.
The lease payment is estimated as monthly depreciation plus a rent charge of (capitalized cost + residual) × money factor, with sales tax applied to that payment in a simplified way. Real dealers may tax the payment, tax the cap reduction up front, or follow a state-specific base. Acquisition fees, disposition fees, required insurance, and excess-mileage charges can swing the comparison.
Use the result to ask better questions, not to sign a contract. If the lease looks cheaper, check the mileage allowance and the residual. If buying looks cheaper, check the APR, the term (long loans can hide expensive cars behind a “low payment”), and a realistic resale value. Always compare out-the-door numbers from the same vehicle and trim.
If a dealer quotes a “payment only” deal, rebuild it in this calculator with the out-the-door price, the real APR or money factor, and a resale or residual you can defend. A lower payment that requires a weaker residual, a longer loan, or a large drive-off check is not automatically the cheaper path.